Former Bay County Historical Society director Mike Bacigalupo is facing a civil lawsuit alleging he improperly used $50,000 from the nonprofit organization for personal purposes.
The legal action, filed in July 2025 by insurer Auto Owners Insurance Group in Bay County Circuit Court, claims Bacigalupo mismanaged funds that were entrusted to him during his tenure as director from 2016 until his resignation in March 2024.
Allegations of Financial Misconduct
According to court filings, the Historical Society issued Bacigalupo more than $140,000 to oversee various projects. However, the lawsuit alleges that approximately $50,000 of that amount was diverted for unauthorized personal use.
The insurer further claims Bacigalupo misrepresented how the funds were spent and failed to repay the amount despite demands. The lawsuit includes allegations of conversion, fraudulent misrepresentation, unjust enrichment, and misuse of funds.
Defense Denies Intentional Wrongdoing
Bacigalupo’s attorney, Jason N. Ball, has denied the accusations, arguing that the funds may have been mistakenly deposited into an account connected to the State Theatre, where Bacigalupo also held a leadership role.
The defense also contends that the claims may be invalid due to legal technicalities, including the statute of limitations and lack of intent.
Broader Legal Troubles and Fraud Case
The lawsuit comes amid wider legal issues for Bacigalupo. In 2025, he pleaded guilty to federal wire fraud charges, admitting he redirected funds from both the Historical Society and the State Theatre between 2020 and 2023.
Investigators say the diverted money was used to finance renovations at Wenonah Park and its band shell in downtown Bay City. Authorities also allege Bacigalupo attempted to conceal the scheme by creating fake documents and seeking a $900,000 federal grant under false pretenses.
His actions reportedly contributed to financial instability for both organizations, including forcing the State Theatre into bankruptcy and delaying key museum renovation projects.
Additional Lawsuits and Financial Liabilities
Bacigalupo has been named in multiple legal actions in recent years. A bankruptcy settlement approved in late 2025 requires him to pay $72,000, alongside additional payments from former board members.
He was also sued by musician Rick Springfield after a $68,750 payment for a performance bounced. A judge has since ruled in Springfield’s favor, awarding the full amount plus interest.
What’s Next
A settlement conference in the Auto Owners lawsuit is scheduled for May 27, while sentencing in the federal fraud case is still pending.