MIDLAND COUNTY, Mich. — A years-long investigation has revealed deep divisions and lasting damage following a sexual abuse scandal tied to Living Word Church, where multiple leaders were convicted of crimes involving children.
The case has raised serious questions about leadership, accountability, and a culture that former members say allowed abuse to go unchecked for years.
Multiple Leaders Convicted in Abuse Cases
Since 2023, three prominent church figures have been charged and convicted in cases involving at least eight minors:
- Brandon S. Saylor — sentenced to 5–15 years after pleading guilty
- Randy L. Saylor — sentenced to 10–25 years after pleading no contest
- James P. Randolph — sentenced to 25–40 years after trial conviction
Two of the men were directly involved in youth ministry, according to investigators and former members.
Survivors testified that abuse in some cases continued for years before being reported.
Survivors Speak Out After Years of Silence
Victims described prolonged abuse and the difficulty of coming forward.
One survivor said she was abused from the age of 12 until adulthood after being placed with a trusted church family. Others said alleged assaults escalated over time and went unreported due to fear and pressure within the community.
Many survivors said they only spoke out after learning of similar allegations involving others.
Questions Over Leadership Awareness
At the center of the controversy is Mark T. Barclay, the church’s founder and leader.
A key dispute remains whether church leadership knew about Randolph’s past conviction for sexual assault before allowing him to work closely with youth.
- Barclay has said he was unaware of Randolph’s criminal history until 2024
- Prosecutors dispute that claim, alleging leadership had prior knowledge
The issue has become a focal point in determining accountability within the organization.
Allegations of a ‘Culture of Silence’
Former members and victims describe an environment where questioning leadership was discouraged.
They allege:
- Criticism of leadership was labeled as disloyal or harmful
- Fear of social or spiritual consequences prevented reporting
- Members who left the church were publicly criticized
Some described the atmosphere as “cult-like,” contributing to delayed reporting of abuse.
Church Growth and Financial Structure Under Scrutiny
Over nearly five decades, Living Word Church expanded into a global religious network through Mark Barclay Ministries.
The organization generates revenue through:
- Donations and tithing
- Bible training programs
- Publishing and ministry events
Critics have questioned the contrast between the church’s financial model and the abuse allegations involving its leadership.
Apology Fails to Heal Divisions
After initial denials, Barclay later issued a public apology following one of the convictions.
However, some survivors rejected the statement, calling it insincere and highlighting years of being dismissed or discredited.
“Lives have been damaged,” one survivor said, pointing to the long-term emotional and psychological impact.
Lasting Impact on Community
Despite the convictions, the church continues to operate, hosting large services and maintaining its global outreach.
Still, former members say trust has been deeply shaken, and the scandal has permanently altered how many view the institution and its leadership.